18 August 2005

Florida Teacher Suspended For Letter To Congressman

Orange County (Florida) teacher Jan Hall has been suspended for a letter she wrote to her Congressman about the problems caused by the Puerto Rican children (and teachers) in her school, Sadler Elementary.

An Orange County elementary school teacher was suspended Wednesday over a letter asking for laws to be changed to prevent Puerto Ricans from coming to Orlando because they are “destroying the city every day,” according to a Local 6 News report.

A handwritten letter by Sadler Elementary School teacher Jan Hall was addressed to a congressman and published in a local Spanish newspaper.

Hall’s letter said Hispanics are causing American students to fall behind in school, Local 6 News reported.

“Schools are dealing with too many problems which originate in the language differences and that takes teaching time away from our American children whose parents do pay taxes,” the letter said.

The letter has angered parents and members of the Hispanic community.

“I don’t think she should be teaching at all,” parent Betsy Santos said.

The Orange County School Board took action Wednesday after reading the letter.

local6.com - News - Teacher Suspended Over ‘Puerto Ricans Destroying Orlando’ Letter

She also said

“Puerto Rican teachers who work at my school are constantly asking me for help with math because they only received the equivalent of a fifth-grade education in Puerto Rico.”

The Attorney For the School Board, Frank Kruppenbacher, said that she won’t be back to that school, no matter what, and she’s been placed on unpaid suspension.

Of course, the school board isn’t allowed to control teachers’ political opinions. But they keep trying.

The problems she referred to are the same ones seen in California, with the Hispanic immigrant population. The difference is that thanks to America’s victory in the Spanish-American War, there’s nothing that can be done about Puerto Rican migration to the mainland.

The Puerto Rican population of Orange County is large enough to make it worth a story in the Puerto Rican Herald complaining that the County wasn’t allocating enough money to teach English.

Email Sadler School Principal Anne Lynaugh.

Update:

The district sent counselors to Sadler Elementary today, to help students who might have heard about the letter that triggered the suspension of teacher Jan Hall.Teacher’s letter is ‘no reflection’ of school’s staff - OrlandoSentinel.com: News

Are these supposed to be “grief counselers” or victory counselors? The only person injured here is the teacher, as far as I can see.

Updating Again:

It was El Nuevo Dia of Orlando that first published the letter, and it’s all Sadler Elementary School, all the time, at their website. Here’s their version of the story in English, and here’s a link to their original story, with the letter translated into Spanish.

Here is an automatic translation back into English. The odd gap in the middle of word “Tuberculosis” is caused by the software refusing to allow bad words, the missing two syllables being Spanish for rear end.

Happy Birthday, Virginia Dare!

A kind reader reminds me today (August 18) was Virginia Dare’s birthday, in 1587. I keep meaning to expand our coverage of this important cultural icon - maybe next year!

What use is Victor Davis Hanson?

When , in the 1960s, the networks began to feel heat for their systematic exclusion of conservative viewpoints, they responded by inventing a new species: the ostensibly well-credentialed individual who, representing the conservative case, would make sometimes elaborate but ultimately ineffectual arguments, and, in the end, always cave in on matters of substance.

Nowadays this species is almost extinct, its habitat having been largely grabbed by neoconservatives, who are of course neither conservative nor ineffectual. Odd examples persist, like George Will.

Victor Davis Hanson seems to have been awarded this role in that section of the Republican-Lackey MSM that pretends to be “Conservative”. A good example is his recent essay “Guest worker wilderness,” The Washington Times, August 13 2005.

This piece is a long moan about the immigration debacle, which however rejects the “guest worker” or ‘bracero” solution. It makes vague reasonable noises:

we are back to the one solution of measured and legal immigration that we all know will work but apparently dread:
Control our borders and enforce existing laws. Fine employers who hire illegal immigrants. Provide a mechanism of foolproof identification. Return to policies of English-language immersion and cultural assimilation. Pay more now in higher labor costs — but save far more later by avoiding entitlement, law-enforcement and social chaos

but in fact sells the pass:

And, most controversially, work out a one-time-only citizenship plan for those who have resided for substantial time in the United States.

In other words–amnesty! (Yessir, Mr President!) No mention at all of the crucial issue of anchor babies, which as a resident of California cannot have escaped his attention.

This uselessness was apparent in Hanson’s book Mexifornia of which my brother said here:

Mexifornia’s reception by establishment conservativism has been surprisingly favorable…It is painfully apparent that this is because of the accident of military historian Hanson’s cheerleading for the Iraq War in National Review and elsewhere…another reason for Mexifornia’s mild reception (is that) it just didn’t frighten immigration enthusiasts enough.

My deference to Victor Davis Hanson as an historian evaporated after reading F. Roger Devlin’s devastating critique of his opportunism as a scholar. [The Case of Victor Davis Hanson: Farmer, Scholar, WarMonger, The Occidental Quarterly Winter 2004]

More recently in Victor Hanson: Portrait of an American Traitor, Gary Brecher, The Exile, July 28 2005 , the vulgar and profane genius writing as the War Nerd gives, I think, an unaswerable assessment of Hanson’s current comments on Iraq. The unusually explicit last paragraph deserves careful attention.